Bayer Study: 6 Causes for Yearly Decline in Veterinary Visits

Bayer Animal Health, Brakke Consulting and the National Commission on Veterinary Economic Issues (NCVEI) announced today results of the Bayer Veterinary Care Usage Study, a comprehensive investigation into reasons for the decline in companion animal veterinary visits over the past several years.  The study identified six root causes:

  • The economic impact of the recession;
  • Fragmentation of veterinary services;
  • Consumers substituting Internet research for office visits;
  • Feline resistance;
  • Perception among pet owners that regular medical check-ups are unnecessary; and
  • Cost of care.

“By far the most important finding, from a pet health perspective, is the misperception by many pet owners that regular medical check-ups for pets are unnecessary,” said Ian Spinks, president and general manager of Bayer Animal Health North America.  “This could be driven by the absence of professional patient care guidelines that recommend annual physicals. The unintended consequence is that many pets aren’t getting the care they need for healthy, long lives.”

The study included individual interviews and focus groups with veterinarians, focus groups with pet owners and a nationally representative survey of 2,000 owners of dogs and cats to determine the factors contributing to the decline in veterinary visits and to test propositions that would encourage pet owners to increase their visits.

The Value Proposition for Regular Veterinary Care and the Role of the Internet

“People often associate clinic visits with ‘shots,’ or vaccinations,” said Karen Felsted, CPA, MS, DVM, CVPM, and CEO of NCVEI, a professional organization dedicated to improving economic conditions in veterinary medicine.  “But that’s not all that happens during a visit.  Veterinarians perform a full physical exam on the pet during which they look for problems with the eyes, ears, skin, internal organs and other body systems.  Pets, like people, can develop health conditions that, if undetected, become costly-to-treat chronic illnesses.  That’s why regular check-ups are important.”

Older animals, in particular, are susceptible to a range of chronic and costly illnesses like diabetes, cancer, and arthritis.  But pet owners who responded to the survey believed by a wide margin that older pets require less medical attention than younger animals, and that indoor pets need next to no veterinary care because they are less exposed to environmental threats.

Another factor that can negatively affect pets and their health is the ready availability of information online.   Fifteen percent of pet owners said that with the Internet they don’t rely on the vet as much; 39 percent look online before consulting a vet if a pet is sick or injured.  “This means veterinarians often see sicker pets because the owner has delayed treatment based on something they read online,” said Dr. Felsted.

The Recession, Cost of Care and Fragmentation of Services

Fifty-six percent of veterinarians who responded to a recent survey conducted by the NCVEI reported that patient visits for the first nine months of 2010 were down compared to the same period in 2009.  But declines in veterinary visits have been documented as far back as 2001, while the population of dogs and cats in the U.S. has steadily increased year over year.

Another contributing factor to visit decline is industry-wide fee increases throughout the last decade and the associated higher veterinary costs that clients experience.  Fifty-three percent of pet owners surveyed reported that the costs of a veterinary visit are usually much higher than they expected.  Affluence also plays a role: as household incomes decline, so do veterinary visits.

“Veterinarians must learn to manage pricing and communicate the value of regular care to avoid deterring pet owners from making annual visits a priority,” said Ron Brakke, president and founder of Brakke Consulting.  “Veterinarians can take specific actions to grow client traffic and improve pet care.  As a profession, veterinarians need a consistent message about the importance and frequency of veterinary care.  It is likely that the trend can be reversed, if the proper actions are taken.”

An additional factor is the fragmentation of the veterinary service options that pet owners have.  Now, more than ever, pet owners can take pets for treatment to veterinarians at mobile vaccination clinics, animal shelters and pet store clinics.  These visits may offset annual visits with their regular veterinarian.

Cats – 1; Vets – 0

Among the most surprising findings was that one-third of cats owned by study respondents have not seen a veterinarian in the last year.  This in part is attributed to “feline resistance,” a catch-all term defining the hiding, aggression, vocalization, and stressed/fearful behavior cats exhibit when crated and transported to unfamiliar surroundings.  Unwilling to do battle with their pets, cat owners become more comfortable with longer time between exams.  This can be especially harmful for older cats, which are more prone to diabetes, kidney failure and cancer than dogs.

About the Bayer Veterinary Care Usage Study

The study objectives included measuring pet owner perceptions of the need for veterinary services, obstacles to scheduling office visits, and the role of alternative channels for pet health information and products.  The survey included companion animal veterinarians and U.S. pet owners of all economic levels and major ethnicities.

Bayer Animal Health, Brakke Consulting and NCVEI conducted the study, and collaborated with several university experts.  Brakke Consulting and NCVEI are also assisting in developing solutions to increase veterinary visits.